| Class 2009 | College | |
| Erica Freiert | UMKC | NCAA Division I (CC) |
| Michelle Hicks | Missouri Southern State | NCAA Division II |
| Emily Jordan | Concordia College | NCAA Division III |
| Jody McFarlen | Missouri State University | NCAA Division I |
| Jessica Roberts | Illinois Institute of Technology | NAIA |
| Hannah Winkel | Virginia Wesleyan | NCAA Division III |
| Class 2008 | College | |
| Tara Bailes | Missouri State University | NCAADivision I |
| Rebecca Carter | Grinnell College | NCAA Division III |
| Megan Garrad | William Jewell College | NAIA |
| Jessica McCutcheon | Rogers State University | NAIA |
| Katy McLain | Drury University | NCAA Division II |
| Patsy Middleton | Missouri Valley College | NAIA |
| Lorin Opfer | Truman State University | NCAA Division II |
| Brianna Ragains | Missouri Southern | NCAA Division II |
| Maggie Schrier | Hendrix College | NCAA Division III |
| Class 2007 | College | |
| Elle Holtmann | Rockhurst University | NCAA Division II |
| Laura McElroy | Grinnell College | NCAA Division III |
| Class 2006 | College | |
| Rachel Lavoy | Purdue University | |
| Ashley Meyer | Lynchburg College | |
| Karissa Nedoma | Drury University | |
| Rebecca Robinson | Truman State University | |
| Alaina Williams | Westminster College | |
| Class 2005 | College | |
| Katie Brooks | William Jewell | |
| Shannon Fitzgerald | Northwest Missouri State University | |
| Samantha Knuckles | Northwest Missouri State University | |
| Class 2004 | College | |
| Heidi Bushman | Dixie State College | |
| Erin Creson | Graceland University | |
| Holly Robinson | Missouri Southern | |
| Maddie Senkosky | University of Missouri |
